Teacher comes to us in the night, drawn by the light of our candle’s flames. He knocks on our window, beckons me and Brother into the forest. There are thirteen children behind him already, thirteen flames cupped in their hands, spread like fireflies behind Teacher. It’s Brother’s first time, so his hands shake as we follow through the woods, perhaps from the cold, more likely from stress, and his flame flickers so much I fear it might go out.
Careful. You can’t let it go out. Your brain will go quiet if you do. But I can’t say that, because the truth would stress him more. “Rico, ey, Rico, imagine you’re carrying an egg,” I tell him. “We just gathered it from the barn, still grimy with chicken shit, yeah? And we’re heading to our parents for Mom to prepare us a potato omelet.”
I rub his back as I speak. He’s hot and soft, save for the rough bump of the great scar that goes from his left shoulder to his spine; a mark he bears because of me, because I got him into trouble playing hide and seek in the forest. We didn’t have Teacher to protect us then, and boys our age shouldn’t be roaming these woods alone. I won’t ever let him be hurt again.
He shivers like the moths encircling us. “Costa, I hear them. They’re above us.”
“No one is there. Just me and you and our good teacher and the classmates that you will love very much. Keep your head straight.” I urge him onward, following the small company as we ignore the chitinous bodies on the branches, hibernating on black, glistening cobwebs.
Although most Spiders surveil the town at night, there’s always some left behind. But Teacher knows how to avoid them. He knows the woods like a pickpocket knows the town streets. The rushing river muffles our footsteps, and we reach the cave of learning, our night school.
This cave is dry warm granite, with fire-breathing lizards sleeping on the crannies, others mating by the wall. Their snoring sounds like a burning hearth, a sound keeping the Spiders at bay because they fear the fire.
We feed them splinters of wood and crushed ants. The lizards are friendly to us because we’re kindred. Humans and lizards are both allies of the flame.
Books pile on the warm floor, and on haphazard tables. Smiling warmly behind his beard, Teacher talks to us in hushed whispers, no louder than the wind curving in to leave again. Usually, Teacher lectures us on cosmology, on history, on all the amazing things humans have done and Spiders steal credit for. On why we hide near the flames and protect the truth by speaking it only where they won’t hear. But today is different.
“Today you will practice devouring flames,” Teacher says.
Confusion is written in the looks my classmates exchange. Some even snicker, thinking Teacher is joking. Not me. As Teacher’s first student, I’ve known this time was coming. Yet dread grips me, and my love for the fire is touched by newfound anxiety, like when I burned my tongue on my favorite chicken soup and yelled for Mom to bring me yoghurt. My throat clenches at the thought of swallowing the blistering element.
“Like lizards, we have a bond with the flame,” Teacher says. “Humans shared tales in bonfire since the time of the old kings, and the flames bonded with us, keeping our secrets safe. The flame you bond with won’t harm you.”
Teacher beckons me.
Hesitantly, I take a step forward, but Brother grabs my hand, and I can see he is more afraid than me. His palm is hot as embers, and his eyes are molten coals. I force a grin on my face to mask my own dread. “There’s nothing to fear, Rico, it’s going to be amazing. I have seen men devouring burning swords. Don’t worry, okay?” My brother makes me a stronger, more confident person by being there, simply by needing me to be.
He nods and finally mirrors my smile. His hair is long curls of thick smoke.
Teacher’s hand is gloved in thick rubber, and he holds a hot piece of iron over my candlelight to temper it until it’s orange. To devour flame in its pure form, we first must practice to withstand the heat.
He whispers to me as he massages my neck. “Don’t be afraid, Costa. It’s in your blood.”
“I’m not afraid.”
He knows I’m lying, which I’m not supposed to do in the dark. Lies are reserved for daylight. “Good,” he says anyway. “Now open your mouth, and take a deep breath.”
#
My throat hurts the next day, and I cannot swallow food. I put on a strong face for my brother, even if I cannot hide the grating rasp in my words. I sound like insects are nestled in my larynx, squirming against each other. Teacher gave me a concoction to drink, and it feels like drinking moss, but it helps the pain.
It’s not the pain that worries me though. I’m anxious the Spiders will hear my voice and know what I’m up to, so I avoid speaking.
Dad is loud at breakfast, so I don’t have to talk. He’s always loud when saying something stupid, as if volume will make it smart. They have already made Dad’s brain a mess. He goes to work at the olive farm with his shirt upside down, spiderwebs in his unkempt hair, and mucus smelling like mold on fruit sticking to his shoulders. He spits on his apple twice before eating it for good luck, and others praise him for it.
Mom bobs her head and tells Dad what a wise, open-minded man he is because it’s easier that way. I quietly eat my scrambled eggs, squeeze lemon on top and drink the chamomile tea she made for the throat. I’m glad they believed I only have a cold, but it’s not them I’m afraid of.
The familiar knock comes on our door, rap-pap-pap, and Mom opens with a slight bow.
It’s Unteacher, fifty or more children behind him. He’s tall and thin, and he wears a coat too large for his body, swallowing up his many spindly arms. His head is covered by a ballooning canvas, three times the size of a human head. It must be supported by shafts on his actual head—which I have never seen—because it’s angular, a polyhedron with canvas curving inward on each side, and with six pinholes to see through. I once thought the pinholes also allowed him to breathe, but then Teacher taught us Spiders traverse the space between planets, spinning webs of dark matter that tangles particles to devour. They don’t breathe.
What’s very annoying about those holes is I cannot tell where he is looking. I cannot be sure he is not scanning my throat with his void-penetrating gaze, seeing through sinew, bone, into the esophagus where nests the forbidden kiss of flame.
Remember this hood is not for strength. It’s because they are afraid of the light but still need to surveil us.
Truth cannot quench my fear, not as he brings his head so close to my face, with all these holes and the unseen eyes staring at me. I wish my brother was next to me so I could hold his hand, but I’m also glad he isn’t. He’s hiding in our room, as I instruct him to do every time Unteacher comes. Even if I’m shaking, even if Unteacher is so close to my face I can smell dead flowers on his canvas, the thought of me standing between him and Brother, of Brother safe under his bedsheet, fills my chest with warm determination.
Unteacher drawls and talks fast with something fizzling under his every word, like many pebbles floating down a pipe. “Something is different,” he says. My skin grows cold, and my throat burns as if I’m swallowing the metal again.
“He has a sore throat,” Mom says, her voice trembling with poorly hidden fear. “You know how it is with human kids.”
Unteacher says, “You changed decoration. Very nice.” And he points to a wooden statue Dad bought, shape of a man with many arms, with a crown made of bulbous egg sacs. A disgusting thing I forgot exists in our living room.
Dad makes a bow and a salute, the gesture of his obedience.
Unteacher’s spindly fingers dig into my shoulder, clenching stealthily but with enough force to hurt. He knows. He knows something is different and it’s not the statue. He doesn’t believe the sore throat excuse. He mentioned the decoration to calm the parents, clenches his fist so that I know he’s watching me.
“Time for school,” he says at last, by which he means the Unschool, where we learn only lies.
At least Brother doesn’t have to deal with this. He’ll stay and study what Teacher taught us yesterday. My parents never question this. Ever since my brother got that scar, my parents act as if he stopped existing. I don’t know why they’re so mad at him that they ignore his presence. It was my fault he got that scar. They should be mad at me. But so long as he gets to avoid the Unteacher, I don’t want to disturb that balance.
I fall into a march with the other children, and we whistle rehearsed quotes on our way to school, the blistering sun our witness.
“The world is a flat disc, don’t stray far from home. If you slip past the edge, you will drop forevermore.”
“Grateful are we to the Spiders and the web that spun our town. Concrete, wood, and fire they planted on the earth. Invented the brick, the kiln, and the hearth.”
“Those who denounce these truths—”we halt to spit on the ground twice, stomping our feet in sync“—bastards, off with their heads.”
I dig a nail into my thumb, the sting of it to remind me. Day is theater. Night is school.
Unteacher’s head turns often today, each time to face my direction when our collective recitation cycles back to the words “…fire they planted on the earth.”
#
In the cave of night school again, steel heated by my candle lays at the back of my tongue, tied to a cord. Teacher holds the other end, giving his lecture as he wiggles the hot metal around the insides of my aching throat. It’s not less painful than when it started, but now the pain is familiar, the burn a second breath, residing next to my inhalations and exhalations.
“There are many kinds of fire,” Teacher says. “Fire that comes from burning twigs will not bond with you; it’s alien to your skin, so it will burn you. The one that lives in the bellies of lizards comes from their fallen kin, and so does ours, flames from the burning of fellow humans, a strong bond if it’s a loved one, and growing stronger if you share secrets with the flame.” He sighs. “Even humanborne fire will burn people who never attuned to a flame. In the days of old kings, such people burned during the Gray Revolution. An unfortunate necessity.”
My heart clenches thinking of innocents hurt, only because they never opened up to the flame. I have to make sure Brother attunes properly. Later, when we return, me and Brother huddle by our candles, placing them both on the nightstand that separates our beds.
“Whisper to the fire,” I instruct him, as Teacher once instructed me. “Whisper everything you learned, okay? The flame will keep it safe from them.”
“But won’t we blow it out afterward?”
“Yes, but that’s ok, because we do it in the house, and the flame’s spirit will stay with us as invisible warmth and then tomorrow we light the wick again, and it’s the same flame returning from the air. It’s why we can change candles every day and it’s still the same flame.”
Brother smiles wide, excited at this, and his smile makes me happy. He whispers about all he learned today: the science, the bits of our country’s history, the great poet names. In the end he says, “Flame, thank you for keeping us safe, and letting us learn true things in the dark. Please continue to keep my brother well, and my mom, and even my dad.”
That’s not how the flame works, but I hug my brother anyway and say nothing.
#
Dad is loud again at breakfast. This time he says trees are made of squirrels. Squirrels that spread their arms in the sun too long until their limbs cooked and dried hard as the bark, and then they piled on each other to become trees themselves. So when animals rub against the tree bark it’s because it’s dead rodents all the way into the trunk and they can smell it.
After he says all this, he nods, pleased with himself, scratches his cobwebbed head and rubs in his thumbs the threads that stick to his fingers before licking them.
I ask, “Dad, if all trees are squirrels where did the first tree come from?” Brother clenches his hand around my knee. He doesn’t like when I argue with Dad, which is why I avoid it most of the time, but I cannot always control myself. Stupid things are annoying, when so many smart things exist in the world.
My brother is right though. It just makes Dad angry. I can tell by the way he frowns and lowers his voice when he asks, “Have you been making bad friends at school?” even though that has nothing to do with it. He shakes his head. “Been hearing you talk to yourself in your room as well. Need to keep your head straight, Costa.” Then he runs his coarse palm over my wispy hair, and it feels like sandpaper. “Try wrapping some cobwebs on your head. You’re the right age and it does a man good, keeps his thoughts tight in there. Keep an open mind about it.”
I know you’re not supposed to think about punching your dad, but at times like this, I do. Good thing he’s not suggesting this for my brother, because I wouldn’t be able to control myself. I’m a bad son.
Mom whispers to me, after breakfast. “Leave him be, be patient, it will all pass soon. He won’t put silly webs on your hair.” She caresses my cheek. Her palm is cold but I don’t complain. “We should visit the doctor. It’s been ten days now your throat’s been sore.”
Damn it. I’ve been avoiding using a lot of words, but I couldn’t help myself with Dad.
I ask if my brother can come, and she shakes her head severely. “Stop saying silly things. It’s not funny.”
Her response, like an accusation that I want to bring him out into danger again, fills me with guilt. I tell my brother to wait and I’ll be real quick, and we hug each other tightly and his hug is as warm as the flame.
#
The doctor’s hut is full of herbs, some of which hang in threads—sprigs of lavender and sage that I recognize. He’s a bearded man, though he is younger than Teacher, not yet touched by graying hair. I envy their beards and hope I grow one as well.
As he inspects my throat, he winks, and I can tell he knows. He’s an ally of the teacher. Maybe it’s a beard thing.
The doctor reassures Mom it’ll pass, and urges her to be patient. Really, he tells her the same things I told her, but since he’s an adult, it works better. He gives us a concoction that is clearly the same, moss-tasting one Teacher gave me, and the doctor prescribed it only to calm her. I’ll play along later, tell her it makes me feel even better. I’ll try only saying it during the day though, because I don’t like lying in the night unless I really have to.
When we return, Dad is nowhere to be found. Mom yells his name at our porch, and in the barn, and goes out to search for him in the olive farm.
Brother waits in his room. He tells me, “Unteacher came and took Dad. I couldn’t stop him.”
“Why? Why did Unteacher take him?”
It pains me how glazed with tears Brother’s eyes are. “They know. Unteacher said he had a mission for him. To uncover a secret school. Dad was excited to go.”
#
I feel like a horrible person because I’m happy he’s gone. It’s stupid, and I should be worried that the Spiders are investigating us.
Mom is a better person than me. She folds over the table and cries when she returns.
I carry my candle out, the flame burning, even though there’s sunlight still. I repeat what Brother said, that Dad went on a mission and that he’s fine. “Brother was here and heard everything!”
She turns, her tear-stricken face tired, sad and now also angry with a shrill voice. “Your brother died. He died four years ago. Stop this. Just stop…” She plunges her face into her palms and breaks into choking sobs. “Why couldn’t you just be normal?”
They have made her brain into a tangled mess as well, they must have. She’s confused. I lift the candle and point at him, “He is here, right here!” But she only cries harder and won’t even look that way. My brother looks sad but doesn’t argue.
We retreat to our shared room, and by the bedside, I wrap my arm tight around Brother’s shoulders, feeling his bones as hot as burning wood, the smoky scent of his hair.
“He’s right, Costa,” he says.
I look at his bed: dusty, unused for years. The candle is hot in my hands. “No. No she’s not.”
“Remember when we played hide and seek and you never wanted it to end?”
I always got us into trouble back then. “Yes.”
“Remember how we agreed to play pretend, after we finished playing hide and seek in the forest?”
I don’t want that game to end. “I’m sorry. I’m sorry about everything.”
Brother is heat and smoke, and the sunlight through the window passes through him. He flickers, like the candle flame itself. “It’s not your fault,” he says.
But it is. I’m the one who led him into the forest, four years ago. If I wanted to rebel against the Spiders, I shouldn’t have brought him with me to play my stupid games.
It hurts to remember. Brother stepped on a web as he tried to find me, and a Spider jerked, slicing in its sleep, stupid and mindless, cutting deep into his soft back. If Teacher had not come then I would have flung myself on the Spider as well.
He couldn’t heal Brother. He took me away and helped me burn him, in the quiet of that cave. I watched his body become flames. Teacher pushed a candle on my hands then, and said, “Light the wick, and carry his soul into your candle. Remember, whatever flesh fire may burn, the soul lives on in the flame.”
I was Teacher’s first student, and the fire that burned my brother became my candle flame. He took form again, tendrils of smoke and fire forming an illusion of his shape. “We’ll play a new game,” I told him then. “We’ll play pretend.” and it was like I never lost him at all.
But every game must end.
“It is my fault,” I say. “I need you to forgive me, or I cannot move on. I cannot.”
“Okay.” He palms my hand, and it’s hotter than usual, enough to sting, but in a way that feels comforting, that feels a part of me. “I forgive you.”
“They are blind to you, but we will show them.” My voice shakes with anger. I convince myself I’m a good brother and hope that makes up for my sin of being a bad son. “We will show them all.”
#
The next day, after Unschool, I find a note on the window sill. The letters are a collage, reading,
THEY INCREASED SURVEILLANCE. CANNOT GATHER YOU. COME TO THE CAVE ON YOUR OWN.
Teacher will no longer be coming. It makes sense, but I worry for the new kids. We must plan better. I must help him as his first student.
At midnight, I drape my cloak over my shoulders and hold my candle tightly, Brother’s heat next to me, guiding my steps into the night. We have followed this road many times, seen Teacher use the angle of branches to hide from Spiders, the patterns of smoke to scan and avoid cobwebs. Brother steps forward, catching those threads in his form enough to highlight them but not to burn and alert the Spiders.
To my relief, I manage to find the cave without getting lost or caught. But it’s quiet, save for the snoring, skittering, and the occasional spark of lizards. I’m the first one there.
It’s not a minute later though I hear footsteps. I expect to see the familiar beard, but instead I see the clean-shaven face of Dad.
My heart sinks. Dad shakes his head, spares me a disappointed look. “I have been raising a delinquent.” He raises his voice then. “He’s here!”
No, they should not be able to walk here. Aren’t they afraid of the lizards?
They are many, and they are clicking in a way human steps should not. Four wear no hoods, but their face is a confusing blur, mulberry-shaped, each bulb likely an eye. It hurts to look at them. Only one of them is familiar. Unteacher still wears his hood, same as in the day. He wants me to recognize him.
Dread claws within me. It was a trap set by my own father, at their instruction. I led them here. They followed me.
I’m petrified they’ll steal my flame—steal Brother—so I swallow it on the spot. And my brother disappears.
As the Unteacher steps forward, Dad throws out a salute. “How smart, to use the domain of night, where we expect diurnal creatures not to. To use the forest while we survey the town.”
He does not acknowledge the lizards. I see them distance themselves from every source of flame sound the lizards make in their snoring. He’s still afraid of us.
“This concludes your mission,” Unteacher tells Dad. “It is sad to discover your own blood is an agitator. However, it’s nothing we cannot fix. Be proud. Because of you, we uncovered this entire … secret school. For this, you will be rewarded.”
Dad bows, and before he can speak, one of the Spiders snatches him. Although I want to scream, I hold it for fear the flame might escape through my mouth and they’ll snatch Brother, too.
I quietly watch them as they enwrap Dad in cobweb, stuff his mouth in it until he cannot breathe. And Dad smiles throughout, thinking the cobweb will help him ascend to a higher form.
#
Dad’s funeral takes place in our house, and it becomes a ritual aimed at shaming us more than honoring his memory. The Spiders made sure to remove all signs of cobweb when they put Dad in the open coffin. They don’t want people to know it was their web that killed him. That in their clumsy stupidity, they suffocated him.
“This man died from a heart attack,”say the Spiders loud enough for all to hear, their voice a continuous, patterned crackle like many branches snapping. “Because his only son strayed from the house at times he shouldn’t, and he was so sad he could not take it.”
I’m not his only son. My brother exists.
I go to my room, rush to my brother’s bed, expecting him to materialize over the bedsheets. But he is not. The flame flickers within me, touching the limits of my throat, fanning down to my stomach. My muscles and bones have grown hotter and I fear I will explode and burn down the house.
Brother is within me and won’t come out.
“I’m sorry,” whispers Mom. She’s behind me. “I should have tried harder. Your father loved you more than you know. Even if it seemed he didn’t. He pretended he’s stupid, pretended so hard he convinced himself. Come, you need to be in the living room.”
She tries to usher me out, but withdraws her hand in reflex, as if my skin burned her. I go out on my own, feeling her stare at my back with confused terror. She softens a few steps later, creating her own story to appease herself. “Your fever is burning hot,” she mumbles. “We’ll do something about it once all this is over.”
Once all this is over they’ll take me for questioning. She doesn’t want to accept it, much as she doesn’t want to accept that my skin just burned her hand as if she touched a boiling kettle. I wonder if some part of her could tell this was Brother. That this is his heat.
Lamps shake over our heads, the ceiling creaking with their unbalanced weight. The village people enter for the funeral rites, wearing cowls of mourning, tangled in spiderweb. Although their eyes are hidden in the shade of the cloth, I can feel them following me.
My forest classmates are among them, and their gaze drips venom. I have blown the secret. Even if it was by accident, the night school, the real school is over.
They don’t really hate me. It’s daylight still, and daylight is a time of untruth and theater.
Among the village people, I finally see Teacher, wearing the same cowl he wears at night, but also different. This time it has spiderweb around it, though none of it touches his skin. He’s not enwrapped in it, but wearing it, just enough to fool them.
Warmth rises up in me, that boiling gastric heat moving back from stomach to throat. It lodges itself there, turning hard and hot like a burning coal. Iron-hot fumes hiss out from between my teeth, and in smoke the heat finally takes shape.
My brother is beside me again. He’s fire and smoke wrapped in the illusion of skin, like he’s been for the past two years, since I first lit his candle. Our soul is flame, his heat a part of me.
He whispers, “I’m afraid.”
“Be patient, Brother,” I say, rubbing his shoulder, feeling like I rub my own. “It will pass, Brother, remember. It will pass.” I could not convince myself until now.
Teacher goes from window to window, shutting the curtains. He meets my gaze and taps his throat twice, at the same spot I feel the warm mass. His words return to me, “Remember, whatever flesh the fire may burn, the soul lives on in the flame.”
I ask Mom for a tea, lying that I have a great headache. It’s daylight, lying is easy and practiced.
Spiders look around. They are confused and stupid and cannot tell Teacher apart from themselves. He is camouflaged by their web. They are simple creatures, following threads across the cosmos, thinking that anything wrapped around their spittle is theirs already and not a threat.
How can such stupid creatures overwhelm us? I need to tell them all, tell them how stupid and weak they are and how they could have never discovered fire, kiln, machinery, and especially not weave something as grand as the cosmos.
Once Mom leaves, I barricade the door behind her with a chair, and its leg is charred by my touch. I do it with nonchalance. If you do things with confidence, people and Spiders are slow to question them.
Dark descends as Teacher shuts the final curtain.
My body swells as Brother merges with me. The warm mass in my throat cracks, like firewood turning to cinder, and words come out of my mouth to finally speak the truth. But they don’t shape sentences. Me and my brother as one breathe out flames, and my night-school classmates breathe out flames, and with the rising heat, Dad’s body swells and spits out the web he choked on in a tangled mess that catches fire, too, as the conflagration burns through each web, reaching the skin it touches.
Until we hear the Spiders screaming, and since it’s daylight, we can lie to ourselves that it’s not our own families screaming among them as well.
